Creation of money: Danger by private banks?

Frankfurt – Only the central banks have the license to print money. However, some commercial banks create their own money through their lending. This is calling critics to see the dangers to the financial system. According to the Bundesbank, however, the criticism goes in the wrong direction.

 

Image: Euro coins as gears 

What is money creation by commercial banks?

Borrowing a customer, for example, 1000 euros at a commercial bank, this writes him the amount in his account well and raises in return claims on interest and repayment. Only if the customer actually withdraws the amount in his account as cash or transfers it to an account of another bank, the bank must get money from the central bank. However, only a small part of the bank balance is actually withdrawn and transfers between banks largely offset each other. So it happens that commercial banks create money almost “out of nothing”. They do not have to spend as much central bank money as they credit their clients.

What problem do critics see about money creation by banks?

Banks could become vulnerable to “bank runs,” a widespread fear. During the financial crisis, doubts arose about the solvency of many financial institutions. The savers were afraid that they would not get their savings back, which is why many of them wanted to withdraw their money at the same time. So they demanded more central bank money than the banks had in stock – many banks could not pay anymore.

What does the Bundesbank counter criticism?

It is not justified from the point of view of the monetary authorities. A commercial bank could spontaneously get central bank money in case of cases. To do this, it must deposit collateral, such as securities, with the Central Bank. Only when she does not have enough of it, it gets really tight. But this can not be prevented by the fact that the bank has more central bank money ready, so the argument. It is rather the result of losses, for example with securities transactions. In the financial crisis many banks had lost large sums of money with dubious US home loans.

Can banks draw unlimited money?

Critics warn that the creation of money leads to excessive lending and the formation of financial bubbles, followed by drastic slumps. These financial cycles can then also plunge the real economy into crisis. According to the Bundesbank, however, lending is limited by the demand of companies and private individuals on the one hand and by the weighing of risks and costs by commercial banks on the other hand. Both are also influenced by the key interest rates. How much central bank money the commercial banks have in stock, however, is not decisive. This is also illustrated by the current situation: Since the financial crisis, the amount of central bank money has increased more than sevenfold, most recently due to the multi-billion dollar purchases of securities by the European Central Bank (ECB). At the same time, lending has increased only moderately.

Are profits of commercial banks justified by the lending of self-created money?

From the point of view of the Bundesbank, yes, because this is a compensation for services. On the one hand, banks offer their clients long-term loans and, on the other hand, the possibility of short-term investments. Due to their size, they can also shoulder default risks. However, this requires a functioning regulation, warns the Bundesbank. During the financial crisis, states with billions of taxpayers were responsible for bank losses.

What alternative do critics think about money creation by banks?

The best known proposal is the so-called “full money”. The idea behind this is that in the future, banks should actually have one euro cash for each euro that savers have deposited with them, or keep them in an account with the central bank. Currently, they only have a fraction of them in stock – the so-called minimum reserve is one percent. The full money would mean raising the reserve to 100 percent. Even after the Great Depression, this idea was discussed in the 1930s. Her most famous advocate was the US economist Irving Fisher, who had previously lost almost all of his private wealth as a result of the deep economic crisis.

What does the Bundesbank think of the proposal of the full money?

Not much. It was “very questionable whether this avoids financial cycles on their own,” it says in the monthly report. In addition, this could limit important functions of the banks. For a more stable financial system, other means are needed, such as strengthening the equity of the banks. An important step in the right direction was also the launch of the European banking union combined with a joint European banking supervision under the auspices of the ECB.

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized

Volkswagen Polo Used Cars – compare offers now!

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer from 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, duration 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount 11,480 €, total amount 12,023.40 €. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: effective annual interest rate 3.99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3.92%, monthly installment 211.00 €, 60 installments, term 60 months, net loan amount 11,480 €, total amount 12,660.00 €
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer of 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, duration 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount 10,850 €, total amount 11,363.40 €. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: annual percentage rate 3.99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3.92%, monthly rate 199.42 €, 60 installments, 60 months, net loan amount 10,850 €, total amount 11.965,20 €
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer of 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, duration 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount 10,390 €, total amount 10,881.60 €. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: annual percentage rate 3.99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3.92%, monthly rate 190.97 €, 60 installments, 60 months, net loan amount € 10,390, total € 11,458.20
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer from 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, duration 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount 13,413 €, total amount 14,047.80 €. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: annual interest rate 3.99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3.92%, monthly installment 246.53 €, 60 installments, 60 months, net loan amount 13,413 €, total amount 14,791.80 €
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer from 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, term 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount 12,320 €, total amount 12,903.00 €. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: effective annual interest rate 3.99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3.92%, monthly installment 226.44 €, 60 installments, term 60 months, net loan amount 12.320 €, total amount 13.586,40 €
 

 

 
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer from 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed lending rate pa 1.83%, duration 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount 3.950 €, total amount 4.137,00 €. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: annual interest rate 3.99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3.92%, monthly installment 72.60 €, 60 installments, 60 months, net loan amount 3.950 €, total amount 4.356,00 €
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer from 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, term 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount € 15,850, total € 16,600.20. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: annual interest rate 3.99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3.92%, monthly installment 291.32 €, 60 installments, 60 months, net loan amount 15,850 €, total amount 17,479.20 €
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer from 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, duration 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount 9.999 €, total amount 10.472,40 €. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: annual interest rate 3,99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3,92%, monthly rate 183,78 €, 60 installments, duration 60 months, net loan amount 9,999 €, total 11,026.80 €
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer from 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, term 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount 6.950 €, total amount 7.279,20 €. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: annual interest rate 3.99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3.92%, monthly installment 127.74 €, 60 installments, term 60 months, net loan amount 6,950 €, total amount 7,664.40 €
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer from 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, term 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount € 17,425, total amount € 18,249.60. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: effective annual interest rate 3.99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3.92%, monthly installment 320.27 €, 60 installments, term 60 months, net loan amount 17.425 €, total amount 19.216,20 €
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer from 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, duration 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount 17.925 €, total amount 18.773,40 €. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: annual interest rate 3,99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3,92%, monthly rate 329,46 €, 60 installments, duration 60 months, net loan amount 17,925 €, total amount 19,767.60 €
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer from 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, term 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount 3,500 €, total amount 3,665.40 €. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: annual interest rate 3,99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3.92%, monthly installment 64.33 €, 60 installments, 60 months, net loan amount 3.500 €, total amount 3.859,80 €
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer of 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, duration 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount 13.890 €, total amount 14.547,60 €. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: annual interest rate 3.99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3.92%, monthly installment 255.30 €, 60 installments, term 60 months, net loan amount 13,890 €, total amount 15,318.00 €
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer from 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, term 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount € 8,960, total amount € 9,384.00. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: annual interest rate 3,99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3,92%, monthly rate 164,68 €, 60 installments, duration 60 months, net loan amount 8,960 €, total amount 9,880.80 €
#

Compare Remember

 
You have 0 vehicles in your watchlist

 
You have ~ numberOfFavourites ~ Vehicles in your watchlist For comparison

1) An offer from 1822direkt, Borsigallee 19, 60388 Frankfurt am Main: effective annual interest rate 1.85%, fixed borrowing rate pa 1.83%, duration 60 months, 60 installments, net loan amount 16,450 €, total amount 17,228.40 €. Representative example acc. § 6a PAngV 2/3 of all customers receive: annual percentage rate 3.99%, fixed borrowing rate pa 3.92%, monthly installment 302.35 €, 60 installments, term 60 months, net loan amount 16.450 €, total amount 18.141,00 €
 

 

** Further information on official fuel consumption and official CO2 emissions of new passenger cars can be found in the ‘Guide to Fuel Consumption, CO2 Emissions and Electricity Consumption of New Passenger Cars’, which is available at all outlets and at Deutsche Automobil Treuhand GmbH at www .dat.de is available free of charge.

*** Your details are used by Verivox GmbH exclusively for the provision of our products, consulting and placement services as well as for our own direct marketing purposes (such as our newsletter). This may be done with the involvement of service providers. Disclosure to third parties (eg energy suppliers or telecommunications providers) is only to fulfill the contract or if we are legally obliged to do so . We are happy to send you information about similar products or consulting and brokerage services of Verivox GmbH via your e-mail address. If you no longer wish to receive further information from Verivox GmbH, you may object to the use of your e-mail address at any time by sending an informal message to the following address: Verivox GmbH, Customer Service, Am Taubenfeld 10, 69123 Heidelberg, Germany, by phone 06221 7961-100, by fax to 06221 7961-8669 or by e-mail to service@verivox.de, without incurring other than the transmission costs according to the basic rates.

    Receive new offers by e-mail

    Sign up for the search request now and never miss an offer anymore.

     

     

     

    Posted in Uncategorized